Oleh: Andrew Kemle , Teks aslinya berjudul “Is There a “Self” Left to Talk About? A Reply to Ash P. Morgans”, diterjemahkan oleh Sachadru. Esai ini merupakan bagian dari Simposium Pertukaran Bersama C4SS tentang Anarkisme dan Egoisme. Ash P. Morgans menulis kritik panjang tentang kontribusi yang diberikan oleh sejumlah “moralis”, termasuk saya. Dan ketika membaca tanggapan…

De Andrew Kemle. Artículo original: Is There a “Self” Left to Talk About? A Reply to Ash P. Morgans, del 16 de septiembre de 2022. Este ensayo es parte de un Simposio de Intercambio Mutuo del C4SS sobre Anarquismo y Egoísmo. Ash P. Morgans tiene una larga crítica de las contribuciones hechas por un número…

Ash P. Morgans has a lengthy critique of the contributions made by a number of “moralists,” including myself. And in reading their response I realized that what I thought I had written—a relatively short piece with a narrow-focus—was, in fact, a confused mess. This doesn’t mean I now disagree with my arguments: I still think…

Jason Lee Byas has already articulated what I think is an interesting (and effective) challenge to Max Stirner’s critique of morality, as well as come to a conclusion that I very much endorse: namely, that self-interest and caring for the well-being of others need not be separate concerns. In my view, the most important contribution…