News Flash: We “No Longer Control Our Government”

Posted by Kevin Carson on Feb 8, 2010 in Commentary2 comments

You mean we once did?  I must have missed it when I blinked.

Keith Olbermann recently spent several consecutive shows in hysterics over the Supreme Court’s  People United decision, announcing in the most dramatic tones that “…we no longer control our government.”

What, exactly, does he mean by “no longer?”

Consider:  the Anti-Counterfeiting Trade Agreement (ACTA), which Cory Doctorow describes as “a brutal, unprecedented copyright treaty being negotiated behind closed doors,” has been in the news recently.  Oddly enough, that treaty was drafted with the help of Mr. Faith and Hope’s trade representatives, before the Citizens United decision, as I recall.

The WIPO treaty and Uruguay Round TRIPS accord were ratified by pre-Citizens United Congresses.  So was the DMCA.

As a matter of fact, pretty much the whole of U.S. trade policy is drafted behind closed doors by industry representatives and WTO technocrats, and Congress ratifies the resulting treaties without even reading them.

Other major pieces of legislation passed back when “we” still controlled “our” government include Bush-Cheney’s massive subsidies to the oil industry, the accelerated depreciation allowance, the R&D tax credit, the interest deduction on corporate debt, Charlie “What’s Good for GM” Wilson’s Interstate Highway System, and—well, you get the idea.

How about all those vigorous debates we always have before our big wars, when American “Commanders-in-Chief” are grilled relentlessly and forced to prove to the American people, beyond a reasonable doubt, that a genuine threat exists?   Eh?  Don’t remember that?  Come to think of it, I don’t either.

I do remember, however, what turned out to be a lot of manufactured lies about Kuwaiti incubator  babies and satellite photos of  Iraqi armor massed on the Saudi border.  I remember learning after the fact that the U.S. had encouraging the Kuwaiti government to engage in provocative behavior like slanted oil drilling on the Iraqi border, while April Glaspie reassured Saddam that the U.S. really couldn’t be bothered with trivial crap like one Arab country invading another.  I remember Bush I immediately beginning the shipment of  troops to Saudi Arabia to confront the public with a fait accompli.  And I remember that the latter tactic worked, as yellow ribbons infested the country and people began ostentatiously “supporting the troops.”

Of course none of that’s anything new.  As a matter of fact, according to Samuel P. Huntington the United States was only able to function as “hegemonic power in a system of world order” because it was governed by (ahem) “the president acting with the support and cooperation of key individuals and groups in the Executive office, the federal bureaucracy, Congress, and the more important businesses, banks, law firms, foundations, and media, which constitute the private establishment.”

So the transition from the good old days when we did “control our government” was, shall we say, somewhat less than abrupt.

  • Share/Bookmark
C4SS Research Associate Kevin Carson is a contemporary mutualist author and individualist anarchist whose written work includes Studies in Mutualist Political Economy and Organization Theory: An Individualist Anarchist Perspective, both of which are freely available online. Carson has also written for a variety of internet-based journals and blogs, including Just Things, The Art of the Possible, the P2P Foundation and his own Mutualist Blog.

2 comments

» Comments RSS Feed
  1. It doesn’t seem like the issue is “no longer control” but “we.” Who are “we” that ever controlled the government? Special interests, fat cat banking gangsters, big agribiz, gigantic defense contractors, but not the people. Not for many decades.

    This new ruling seems to imply that any corporate entity could spend as much as it wants on influencing the course of elections. Doesn’t have to be one owned by a giant business concern or a foreign bank.

    But, as before, what part of the election process and influencing it does anything to build a stateless society? Or are “we” not doing that here any longer?

  2. Who are “we” that ever controlled the government? Special interests, fat cat banking gangsters, big agribiz, gigantic defense contractors, but not the people. ***Not ever.***

    fixed that for you.

Leave a comment

You must be registered to post comments.